Monday, May 20, 2024

Tax evasion

Tanzania Military Expels Smugglers From Gemstone Mine

Dar es Salaam, Tanzania — As a newly-wed couple who visited Tiffany and Co Store in New York can attest, the finely crafted wedding rings fitted with velvet blue crystals, capture the allure of Tanzanite—one of the world’s most sought-after gemstones 1000 times rarer than diamond.

What is not so obvious to the revelers, though, is that the dazzlingly glittering stone only found in Tanzania is oftentimes a product of smuggling.

Lucrative Business

Despite being a lucrative business, the global Tanzanite trade has not been giving optimal benefits to Tanzania, the only place on earth where the precious stones are found.

Although the east African country is endowed with huge mineral resources notably Tanzanite gemstones, the local industry for cutting had not developed as fast, as a result, a huge amount of precious minerals is shipped by unscrupulous traders to the far East for processing and value addition.

Tanzanite Discovery

Discovered in 1967 by Meru herdsman, Jumanne Ngoma, who stumbled upon glittering crystals while herding cattle on the foot of Mount Kilimanjaro, Tanzanite, prized between $600-$800 per carat, is arguably the best money can buy.

Tanzanite smuggling
A perimeter wall built by Tanzania military has helped in preventing Tanzanite smuggling and increasing government revenue. Credit: Edwin Mujwahuzi

At a dusty township nestled on Mererani Hills in Tanzania’s northern Manyara region—dotted with wooden shacks, artisanal miners scale down squeaking wooden ladders, into shafts and crawl through narrow passages into underground caves to find their luck.

Driven by survival instinct, the diggers, better known as “Wana Apolo” explore every possible means day and night to find their luck, even though they know much of what they get won’t benefit their families.

“I am working here as an employer, there’s no chance at all I will wake up one day to be rich, whatever we get goes to our boss,” said Halfan Hemed, a miner at Mererani. 

According to him, much of the resources are being stolen by foreigners.

Plugging The Loopholes

In an effort to curb Tanzanite smuggling, former Tanzania president, John Magufuli, in 2017 ordered the military to build a 24km perimeter wall surrounding Tanzanite mining site in the northern Simanjiro district to control theft of the precious gemstone thus preventing loss of government revenues.

Fitted with surveillance cameras and barbed wires, the 20 feet high wall has reportedly helped in the monitoring of suspicious activities in the mining site thus preventing smuggling of the gems.

Million Dollars Loss

The east African country has repeatedly lost millions of dollars due to Tanzanite smuggling.

The government had thus established new regulations to ensure high security and effective management of mining activities in and around the mining site.

The mustard yellow wall, worth $2.9 million, has only one entrance, which is secured by the army.

Before its construction, officials said about 40 percent of all Tanzanite produced in Tanzania was being smuggled out of the country.

Recent government data show that gemstones worth Tzs 635 (US$288.6 million) were being smuggled out of the country every year through illegal routes and the consignment ended up in Kenya, India, and other destinations in the far east.

For instance, records show that Kenya, was is exporting abroad Tanzanite worth $100 million while India pocketed $300 million worth of Tanzanite sales, surprisingly official export figures in Tanzania before construction of the wall clocked at US $38 million per year.

Parliamentary Enquiry

The move to build the wall followed a parliamentary inquiry in 2017, which revealed massive smuggling of the blue-violet gemstone of which mining operators were the ones reaping the benefits of the country’s tanzanite riches due to corruption and bad contracts.

The government move to control mining activities at the Tanzanite site has helped in assuring buyers especially in the United States that the gemstones are legitimate and all relevant taxes and royalties are being paid.

Officials said the government has created infrastructure for the wholesale gemstone industry in the country where gem cutters, carvers, and jewelers compete with others abroad.

Military Might

Speaking at the burial ceremony of the late Magufuli, Chief of Tanzania Defence Forces, General Venance Mabeyo, said the military has been fully involved in the protection of the country’s minerals wealth especially the construction of the wall.

“We wanted to protect the tanzanite mine, and before doing that we have built the wall surrounding it to prevent smuggling,” Mabeyo said.

Since 2016, the east African country overhauled the legal, regulatory and fiscal framework governing the mining sector ostensibly to seal off loopholes for theft and loss of government revenues.

Dotto Biteko, Minister for minerals said the country has seen an increase in government revenues from sales of Tanzanite and other minerals due to coordinated response such as tightened security at airports and border points through which the gemstones and other precious minerals were being smuggled.

“We are better off, far better off than when the situation was six years ago,” he said,

Magufuli strongly criticized foreign mining companies, accusing them of undervaluing their production of gold, diamonds, and tanzanite, resulting in a loss of billions of dollars in taxes and royalties.

A commission of inquiry set up by Magufuli estimated that $90bn had been lost in tax evasion arising from mining operations since 1998.

African CSOs Call On Governments To Participate In The FACTI Panel High-Level Africa Regional Consultation

Nairobi, Kenya November 19 — Civil Society Organizations (CSOs) meeting at the 8th Pan African Conference on Illicit Financial Flows and Taxation in Nairobi have expressed deep concern over African governments limited interest in the High-Level Panel on International Financial Accountability, Transparency, and Integrity for Achieving the 2030 Agenda (FACTI Panel) consultations.

They are calling on African governments to actively participate by providing written and oral input into the FACTI Panel High-Level Africa regional consultations, saying to date, only the governments of the Republic of Sudan, Egypt, Nigeria, and South Africa have confirmed participation at the ministerial level.

The FACTI Panel regional consultations seek to bring together high-level representatives from member states, along with leaders from the private sector, civil society, and academia. 

The inputs from these stakeholders will feed into the FACTI Panel’s determination of technically feasible and politically viable recommendations to be made in its final report in February 2021

On 18th November, the High-Level FACTI Panel and the United Nations Economic Commission for Africa hosted the High-level Africa regional consultation to discuss possible means to address the shortcomings identified in the interim report published by the FACTI Panel on 24 September 2020.

It is only by active participation can African leaders ensure the FACTI Panel’s final report addresses the needs of African countries as losers in a rigged international finance architecture.

The FACTI Panel represents a critical institutional space to call for the implementation of measures targeted at curbing illicit financial flows and widespread tax evasion and tax avoidance that most harm countries in the Global South. 

By participating in the FACTI Panel High-Level Africa Regional Consultation, African leaders can use the opportunity to critique the shortfalls of the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) processes and demand the establishment of a truly inclusive and democratic global tax governance structure.

Reforming the global structure of the international financial architecture and strengthening the fiscal and policy space for socio-economic transformation were key recommendations of the PAC conference.

They also call on African governments to demand that the FACTI Panel explicitly recognizes the immediate need for a universal, intergovernmental tax body at the United Nations, where developing countries can defend and safeguard their national interests through collective action at the United Nations. 

“As Africans, we are saddened with how African Ministers of Finance are taking the FACTI Panel consultations casually. This is the moment to correct an international tax system that has all along been rigged against us. We cannot afford to lose this moment!” Alvin Mosioma, Executive Director, Tax Justice Network Africa (TJNA) told Ubuntu Times in an interview.

In the face of the fundamental lesson that COVID-19 has taught governments, the centrality of public resources to Africa’s development is critical.

“We must all work towards ensuring that the FACTI Panel’s final report builds better on the Mbeki-led High-Level Panel Report on Illicit Financial Flows by clearly framing the analysis around IFFs,” added Mosioma.

According to Munir Akram, the 76th President of the United Nations Economic and Social Council, today, member states face three simultaneous global challenges. These are COVID-19 pandemic and its consequences, the realization of the 2030 Agenda and SDGs and the existential threat of climate catastrophe.

“Adequate financing is key to addressing each one of these challenges. Such financing will have to be mobilized at both the national and international levels. The ability of developing countries to mob dome finance is obviously constrained and this capacity has further diminished due to the impact of Covid-19,” Munir highlighted. 

To allow illicit flows to continue at this time, he adds, would be nothing short of criminal. IFFs deny vulnerable people access to basic services and infrastructure and condemn them to a life of inequality and poverty.

To ensure African governments build back better and sustainably post COVID-19, the CSOs called on African governments to ensure the creation of a truly inclusive architecture of international tax cooperation to end IFFs. 

IFFs deny governments billions of dollars that would otherwise be invested in public services particularly health, education, and social protection. 

African civil societies hosted the 8th Pan African Conference (PAC) on Illicit Financial Flows (IFFs) and Taxation from 9-13 November 2020 whose theme was ‘Africa We Want Post COVID-19: Optimizing Domestic Resource Mobilization from the Extractive Sector for Africa’s Transformation.’

Trust Africa organized the 8th PAC in collaboration with 18 co-conveners, including Tax Justice Network Africa (TJNA), African Union (AU), United Nations Economic Commission on Africa (UNECA), Global Alliance for Tax Justice (GATJ), African Tax Administration Forum (ATAF), OXFAM, Action Aid among others.

Latest Stories

Heads of State for Burkina Faso, Captain Ibrahim Traoré (left) and Colonel Assimi Goïta of Mali (right).

Africa’s Coup Governments: When Elections Become An Exhausted Idea Confirming Democratic Fatigue

4 months ago
The trending successful military coups in West Africa today indicate the continuation of political processes and leadership by another method. Their executions have been...
The Labour Party logo and Peter Obi

Labour Party And The Future Of Radical Politics In Nigeria

4 months ago
Needless to say, the 2023 elections happened amid overwhelming disillusionment with the system and popular discontent with the major establishment political parties—the ruling All...
Good road networks key in trade facilitation

Political Instability, Intra-state Conflicts, And Threats To AfCFTA Agreement’s ‘Made In Africa’ Aspirations

5 months ago
The African Continental Free Trade Area (AfCFTA) is arguably the African Union’s (AU) biggest project since the launch of the continent’s Agenda 2063 in...
Picture of journalists and victims of forced evictions in Mosafejo-Oworonshoki

How The Lagos State Government Demolished Houses Of Low-Income Earners In Mosafejo-Oworonshoki, Forced Over...

5 months ago
In a sudden turn of events, piles of wreckage became the only remnants of what used to be homes to over 7,000 people, women,...
African leaders pose for a photo in St. Petersburg, Russia.

Russia-Africa Relations: Africa’s Entanglement With Politics Of Patronage Without Liberation

7 months ago
There are intense political and intellectual debates unfolding in Africa. Since February 24 last year, when war broke out in Europe following Russia’s special...
Protestors at a mine at the settlement of Uis in Namibia's Erongo region

Namibia Lithium Battle

7 months ago
On June 27, 2023, a judge of the High Court of Namibia, Ramon Maasdorp, ruled that the Southern African country’s Minister of Mines and...
Operation Dudula supporters marched in the Johannesburg Central Business District.

Operation Dudula

8 months ago
There is no direct translation for the word Dudula in the English language, but the president of the organization that started off as a...
Lunch hour in Windhoek's Central Business District (CBD) with residents walking through Post Street Mall, Windhoek's main business center..

The Tragedy Of Namibia’s Working Poor

8 months ago
At the dawn of independence in 1990, a public servant working in an entry-level position for the state could afford to buy themselves a...
The Economic Freedom Fighters (EFF) celebrate 10 years at the FNB stadium in Johannesburg.

Economic Freedom In Our Lifetime

8 months ago
A packed FNB stadium with over one hundred thousand supporters demonstrated the mass appeal of the Economic Freedom Fighters (EFF) amongst South African voters...
Monica Geingos, First Lady of the Republic of Namibia and President of the Organization of African First Ladies for Development.

Organization Of African First Ladies For Development

8 months ago
The Organization of African First Ladies for Development (OAFLAD) launched the #WeAreEqual Campaign on Wednesday, August 23, 2023, at a banquet ceremony held in...
Dumisani Baleni EFF South Africa Communications officer for Gauteng Province, South Africa.

EFF Confronts Racism In South African Schools

8 months ago
An incident involving a thirteen-year-old girl child at the Crowthorne Christian Academy in South Africa led to the schools' closure and the re-sparking of...
African leaders discussed the African Continental Free Trade Area (AfCFTA) at the 36th African Union (AU) Summit held on 18th February 2023 at the AU headquarters in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia.

Africa’s Rebirth At 60: Carrying Noble Ideas That Nobody Is Willing To Implement

8 months ago
To most academics, intellectuals, and pragmatists advocating for a genuine Pan-African renaissance six decades after the founding of the Organisation of African Unity (OAU,...
Photo Of newly inaugurated President, Bola Tinubu, and immediate past President, Muhammad Buhari.

Tinubu’s Inauguration: End Of An Error, The Dawn Of Calamity

8 months ago
"I am confident that I am leaving office with Nigeria better in 2023 than in 2015." President Buhari ended his farewell speech with this...
Zimbabwe’s President posing for a photo with his guests.

IMF And World Bank: The ‘Bad Samaritans’ And Neoliberals Cheating Africa Into A Cycle...

8 months ago
The Western liberal consensus has long been intervening and interfering in Africa. The first form of intervention was through the slave trade from the...
A picture of the leading presidential candidates at the just concluded Nigerian 2023 polls

2023 Elections: A Street Robbery

12 months ago
If you can relate with the kind of mood you'd meet when on a visit to a street that had just experienced a robbery...